"Russia's war against Ukraine cannot be holy," - WCC responds to Patriarch Kirill

This was declared in the statement of the WCC.

As reported previously, on 27 March, under the chairmanship of the head of the Russian Orthodox Church, Patriarch Kirill, the Decree of the XXV World Russian People's Council "The Present and Future of the Russian World” was approved.

This decree, which is addressed to the legislative and executive authorities of Russia, has raised grave concerns among WCC member churches.

The World Russian People's Council is the largest Russian public forum, and according to its Statutes, the head of the council is the Patriarch of Moscow and All Russia, under whose presidency the annual council meetings are held.

“Among other concerns arising from the recent decree,” said Pillay, “the World Council of Churches cannot reconcile the statement that ‘the special military operation [in Ukraine] is a Holy War’ with what we have heard directly from Patriarch Kirill himself, nor with relevant WCC governing body policy pronouncements, nor indeed with the biblical calling for Christians to be peacemakers in the midst of conflict.”

In a meeting with the WCC General Secretary in Moscow in May 2023, Patriarch Kirill said that any references he had made to “Holy War" in the current context were related to the metaphysical realm, not to the physical armed conflict in Ukraine. He agreed with the WCC General Secretary that no war of armed violence can be 'holy'. The decree contradicts this position,” Pillay noted.

Since the Russian invasion of Ukraine in February 2022, WCC’s highest governing bodies – the central committee in June 2022 and the WCC 11th Assembly in September 2022 – have strongly affirmed the position that “war is incompatible with God’s very nature and will for humanity and against our fundamental Christian and ecumenical principles.

They explicitly denounced the invasion of Ukraine as “illegal and unjustifiable.” In addition, the WCC rejected any misuse of religious language and authority to justify armed aggression and hatred.

The Russian Orthodox Church was represented in both of these key governing body meetings and in the processes leading to the adoption of these statements.

“In light of the established positions of the WCC’s highest governing bodies, the WCC cannot accept the decree’s presentation of Russia’s illegal and unjustifiable invasion of its sovereign neighbour Ukraine as ‘a new stage of the national liberation struggle of the Russian people against the criminal Kyiv regime and the collective West behind it, conducted in the lands of South-Western Russia since 2014,’ or the perspective that ‘all territory of modern Ukraine should enter into a zone of exclusive influence of Russia,’” said Pillay.

The WCC General Secretary addressed Patriarch Kirill, seeking clarifications on whether this decree should be understood as expressing the Russian Orthodox Church’s position, how such positions can be held by a member church of the World Council of Churches, and how they can be squared with what he has heard directly from the Patriarch himself.

"An urgent meeting has been requested to discuss this matter and to find ways in which the concerns raised within the fellowship can be addressed,” said Pillay.